December 5 Wednesday – The London Morning Post in “Literary Notes” p.6:

Having provided a grievous disappointment in Tom Sawyer Abroad, Mark Twain has produced, in Pudd’nhead Wilson, a book which must add considerably to its author’s reputation. Even the most devoted lover of Mark Twain’s writings could not have anticipated that he would produce a work of such strength and such serious interest as this [Budd, Contemporary Reviews 359].

The Glasgow Herald p.10:

Pudd’nhead Wilson is not exactly a nice story, but it is certainly fresh enough and exciting enough, and contains plenty of strong and original situations [360].